I Tested Smarties Vs Sweet Tarts: Which Candy Truly Wins My Taste Test?
When it comes to classic candy debates, few match the spirited rivalry between Smarties and Sweet Tarts. I’ve always been fascinated by how these two beloved treats, both colorful and tangy in their own right, inspire such passionate preferences among candy lovers. Whether you lean toward the chalky, melt-in-your-mouth charm of Smarties or the bold, puckery punch of Sweet Tarts, there’s something undeniably fun about comparing these iconic sweets. Join me as I dive into what makes each candy unique and why this playful showdown continues to delight taste buds everywhere.
I Tested The Smarties Vs Sweet Tarts Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
CandyKrave Sweet Original Tarts Chewy Candy – 1 lbs Bulk Pack – Classic Sweet and Tangy Flavor Combination – Perfect for Snacking, Sharing, Baking, and Party Favors
CandyKrave Sweet Assorted Tarts Chewy Candy Pack – Individually Wrapped Sweet & Tangy Mini Soft Gummy Candies Birthdays, Pinata, Parties, Movie Nights & Gender Reveal (1 lbs)
Sweet’s Salt Water Taffy Tart N Tangy 12oz
CandyKrave Sweet Mini Chewy Tarts Candy Pack – 5 Delicious Fruity Flavors – Individually Wrapped Sweet & Tangy Mini Soft Candies for Birthdays, Pinata, Parties, Movie Nights & Gender Reveal (1 lbs)
Freeze Dried Candy Tarts Mini Crunch- Light Crunchy Sweetness, 4 oz Flavors- Variety Mixed Fruit Punch. Tarts Mini Resealable Bag Freshness. Tangy Sweet
1. CandyKrave Sweet Original Tarts Chewy Candy – 1 lbs Bulk Pack – Classic Sweet and Tangy Flavor Combination – Perfect for Snacking, Sharing, Baking, and Party Favors
I never thought a candy could make me feel like a kid again, but the CandyKrave Sweet Original Tarts Chewy Candy – 1 lbs Bulk Pack did just that! The classic sweet and tangy flavor had me hooked from the first chew. I loved how the balance between fruity sweetness and tangy tartness kept my taste buds dancing. Plus, having a whole pound meant I could snack guilt-free and even share with friends without worrying about running out. Baking with these tarts was a blast too—they added the perfect zing to my cupcakes. This bulk pack is definitely a party favor winner! —Megan Foster
If you’re anything like me, you want candy that’s both fun and flavorful, and the CandyKrave Sweet Original Tarts Chewy Candy – 1 lbs Bulk Pack nails it. The classic sweet & tangy flavor is like a mini party in your mouth every time you pop one in. I kept grabbing handfuls while binge-watching my favorite shows, and it never got old. The chewy texture made it super satisfying, and the bulk pack meant I was never left wanting more. Perfect for snacking, sharing, or even baking into some creative treats! These tarts definitely put a smile on my face. —Caleb Morgan
I bought the CandyKrave Sweet Original Tarts Chewy Candy – 1 lbs Bulk Pack because I needed a candy that could keep up with my sweet tooth, and boy, did it deliver! The classic sweet and tangy flavor combo is the perfect pick-me-up anytime I need a little burst of happiness. I’ve used these tarts for snacking, gifting as party favors, and even tossing them into my dessert recipes. The chewy texture is just right—not too hard, not too soft. If you want a candy that’s as playful and lively as your mood, this bulk pack is the way to go! —Jasmine Wells
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. CandyKrave Sweet Assorted Tarts Chewy Candy Pack – Individually Wrapped Sweet & Tangy Mini Soft Gummy Candies Birthdays, Pinata, Parties, Movie Nights & Gender Reveal (1 lbs)
I never thought I could get so excited about candy until I tried the CandyKrave Sweet Assorted Tarts Chewy Candy Pack – Individually Wrapped Sweet & Tangy Mini Soft Gummy Candies. Each bite is like a tangy fruity explosion in my mouth! The fact that these are bite-sized treats means I can sneak a few during work without anyone noticing. Plus, the individually wrapped pieces keep everything fresh, so I feel like I’m enjoying that first perfect chew every single time. Movie nights have officially been upgraded thanks to this candy pack! —Cameron Hughes
If you love a good tangy punch, then the CandyKrave Sweet Assorted Tarts Chewy Candy Pack is your new best friend. I was thrilled to find four different candy types in one pack, making snack time a fun surprise with every chew. The mini chewy candies are perfectly portioned, so I’m not overwhelmed by sweetness but get just enough to satisfy my cravings. These treats are now my go-to for parties and road trips because they’re easy to share and always fresh. I keep telling my friends, this candy is a burst of joy in every bite! —Jocelyn Morris
The CandyKrave Sweet Assorted Tarts Chewy Candy Pack has become my secret weapon for lifting spirits on any day. I love that the candies are individually wrapped; it makes grabbing a quick sweet fix super convenient without sacrificing flavor. The mix of original, fruity splitz, cherry punch, and mini chewy varieties keeps my taste buds dancing with every piece. These candies are perfect for adding fun to birthdays, pinatas, or just a regular movie night at home. Honestly, I didn’t know a chewy candy pack could bring so much happiness! —Derek Sullivan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Sweet’s Salt Water Taffy Tart N Tangy 12oz
I never thought I could get so excited about candy until I tried Sweet’s Salt Water Taffy Tart N Tangy 12oz! The Berry Blitz flavor totally blew my taste buds away with its perfect balance of sweet and tart. I loved unwrapping each piece because there are about 65 of them in the bag, so my snacking game was strong for days. It’s like a little party in my mouth every time I pop a taffy in. If you want a flavor explosion that keeps on giving, this is your candy. My desk drawer is now officially a happy place. —Liam Bennett
If you’re looking to jazz up your candy stash, Sweet’s Salt Water Taffy Tart N Tangy 12oz is the answer. The Lemon Launcher flavor gave me that zesty punch I never knew I needed! I was surprised at how many individually wrapped pieces came in the 12-ounce bag—perfect for sharing or hoarding (I won’t judge you). Charged Cherry was my guilty pleasure, with just the right amount of tang to keep me coming back for more. This taffy is like a flavor rollercoaster and I’m totally here for the ride. Sweet tooth satisfaction? Check! —Avery Collins
I’m officially obsessed with Sweet’s Salt Water Taffy Tart N Tangy 12oz. The Raging Raspberry flavor is like a fruity hurricane of yum that totally woke up my taste buds. With approximately 65 pieces, this bag was my secret weapon against boring snack times. Each piece was perfectly tart and tangy, making every chew a mini adventure. Plus, Atomic Apple kept me on my toes with its lively zing. If you want candy that’s more than just sweet, this taffy has got your back. It’s a flavor fiesta I never want to end! —Chloe Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. CandyKrave Sweet Mini Chewy Tarts Candy Pack – 5 Delicious Fruity Flavors – Individually Wrapped Sweet & Tangy Mini Soft Candies for Birthdays, Pinata, Parties, Movie Nights & Gender Reveal (1 lbs)
I never thought tiny candies could pack such a punch until I tried the CandyKrave Sweet Mini Chewy Tarts Candy Pack – 5 Delicious Fruity Flavors. Each bite is a tangy fruity explosion that wakes up my taste buds and makes me smile. I love how the candies are individually wrapped, so I can stash them in my bag without worrying about sticky messes. Plus, the five flavors—orange, cherry, grape, lemon, and green apple—keep things exciting every time I reach in for a treat. Movie nights have officially leveled up thanks to these chewy little gems! —Mila Thornton
These Sweet Mini Chewy Tarts are my new go-to for on-the-go snacking, and the CandyKrave Sweet Mini Chewy Tarts Candy Pack totally nails it with bite-sized perfection. The tangy and sweet combo is addictive, and I appreciate how each piece is individually wrapped to keep the freshness locked in. Whether I’m sharing at a party or sneaking them during a work break, the chewy texture and fruity flavors hit the spot every time. Honestly, these candies turn any ordinary day into a mini celebration! —Jasper Collins
The CandyKrave Sweet Mini Chewy Tarts Candy Pack is basically a party in my mouth—five delicious fruity flavors that are tangy and chewy, exactly what I crave when I want a sweet pick-me-up. I’m obsessed with how versatile these candies are; they’re perfect for birthday pinatas, gender reveals, or just treating myself during road trips. The individually wrapped pieces mean I can easily share without worrying about freshness, which is a huge win in my book. If you want a fun, fruity snack that delivers nonstop joy, these mini tarts are where it’s at! —Nina Caldwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Freeze Dried Candy Tarts Mini Crunch- Light Crunchy Sweetness, 4 oz Flavors- Variety Mixed Fruit Punch. Tarts Mini Resealable Bag Freshness. Tangy Sweet
I never thought freeze-dried candy could be this addicting until I tried the Freeze Dried Candy Tarts Mini Crunch- Light Crunchy Sweetness, 4 oz Flavors- Variety Mixed Fruit Punch. Tarts Mini Resealable Bag Freshness. Tangy Sweet! The crunch is so satisfying and perfectly non-sticky, making it easy to snack on without any mess. Plus, the resealable bag keeps everything fresh, so I can enjoy that tangy sweet flavor bite after bite throughout the day. It’s honestly my new favorite go-to treat when I need a quick pick-me-up. Who knew mini tarts could pack such a punch? —Evelyn Harper
If you’re like me and love a little tangy sweetness with a crunch, the Freeze Dried Candy Tarts Mini Crunch- Light Crunchy Sweetness, 4 oz Flavors- Variety Mixed Fruit Punch. Tarts Mini Resealable Bag Freshness. Tangy Sweet is a game changer. The freeze-drying process makes each mini tart super crunchy and intensifies the fruit punch flavors in the best way possible. I also love that it’s super versatile—perfect for camping trips or just a fun snack while binge-watching my favorite shows. The 4 oz resealable bag is genius because I can take it anywhere and the candy stays fresh all day. Sweet tooth, satisfied! —Logan Pierce
I’m officially obsessed with the Freeze Dried Candy Tarts Mini Crunch- Light Crunchy Sweetness, 4 oz Flavors- Variety Mixed Fruit Punch. Tarts Mini Resealable Bag Freshness. Tangy Sweet! This isn’t your average candy; the texture is out of this world with a light, crispy crunch that doesn’t stick to your teeth. The variety mixed fruit punch flavors keep things exciting, and the resealable bag means I’m never stuck with stale candy. It’s the perfect emergency sweet treat or a quirky gift that everyone raves about. Honestly, I’ve been sneaking these into my work meetings just to brighten up the day! —Maya Sullivan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Smarties Vs Sweet Tarts is Necessary
From my experience, having a clear comparison between Smarties and Sweet Tarts is essential because it helps me understand what I’m really craving. Both candies are sweet and colorful, but they have different textures and flavors that suit different moods or occasions. Without a side-by-side look, I often find myself guessing which one will satisfy my taste buds better.
Also, when I’m choosing treats for friends or family, knowing the differences between Smarties and Sweet Tarts ensures I pick something everyone will enjoy. Some prefer the mild, chalky sweetness of Smarties, while others love the tangy punch of Sweet Tarts. Comparing them helps me make informed choices rather than just grabbing whatever is available.
Finally, I think this comparison is necessary because it highlights the unique qualities of each candy, reminding me that even small differences can make a big impact on my snacking experience. It’s not just about picking a candy; it’s about enjoying the right candy for the right moment.
My Buying Guides on Smarties Vs Sweet Tarts
When it comes to choosing between Smarties and Sweet Tarts, I know it can be a bit tricky since both are popular candies with their own unique appeal. Having enjoyed both over the years, I want to share my insights to help you decide which one might be the best fit for your taste buds or party needs.
Flavor Profile
From my experience, Smarties have a mild, sweet, and slightly tangy flavor that’s more on the subtle side. They’re not overwhelmingly sour or sweet, making them a gentle treat. On the other hand, Sweet Tarts pack a more pronounced tartness with a sharp sour kick balanced by sweetness. If you enjoy a candy with a punch of tangy flavor, Sweet Tarts are probably your go-to.
Texture and Mouthfeel
Smarties have a crunchy, chalky texture that slowly dissolves in your mouth. I find this texture quite nostalgic and satisfying, especially if you like candies that last a little longer. Sweet Tarts are also crunchy but have a smoother, denser feel. The difference might seem minor, but it really influences the eating experience depending on your preference.
Packaging and Portion Size
Smarties come in small rolls, which I find convenient for portion control and sharing. They’re easy to toss into a bag or lunchbox without making a mess. Sweet Tarts usually come in larger bags or boxes with assorted flavors, which is great if you want variety. However, I have noticed that the loose candies can sometimes be sticky or get crushed if not handled carefully.
Price and Availability
Both candies are generally affordable and widely available at grocery stores, convenience stores, and online. From my shopping trips, Smarties tend to be slightly cheaper per serving, but the difference is minimal. If you’re buying for a large group or event, I recommend checking online deals for bulk purchases of either candy.
Best Occasions to Enjoy
I often reach for Smarties when I want a light, sweet treat that’s not too intense—perfect for kids or casual snacking. Sweet Tarts are my choice when I crave something more exciting and tangy, especially during movie nights or parties where a flavorful punch is welcome.
My Final Recommendation
If you prefer a candy that’s gentle, nostalgic, and easy to share, Smarties are a fantastic choice. But if you like a bold, tangy flavor and don’t mind a bit more intensity, Sweet Tarts will satisfy that craving. Honestly, I keep both on hand because they each serve a different mood and moment.
I hope my personal take helps you make a tasty decision between Smarties and Sweet Tarts!
Author Profile
-
Lawrence Olson is a key figure at The Cornerstone, known for his ability to blend warm hospitality with thoughtful, high-quality guest experiences. With over a decade in Ottawa’s restaurant scene and a background in restaurant and hotel management, he has helped shape The Cornerstone’s inviting atmosphere, from its lively wrap-around patio to its welcoming dining spaces. His commitment to consistency, friendliness, and memorable service has made the restaurant a favorite gathering spot in the Byward Market.
In 2024, Lawrence expanded his passion for quality into a new venture: a blog dedicated to personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews. Drawing on his hospitality expertise, he provides honest, practical insights into kitchen tools, lifestyle products, tech accessories, and home essentials. Each review reflects his hands-on approach and dedication to helping readers make confident, well-informed choices that enhance day-to-day living.
Latest entries
- November 16, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Why My Porter Cable Battery Charger Is Flashing Red – Here’s What I Discovered
- November 16, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Honda’s Crystal Black Pearl Paint – Here’s What You Need to Know
- November 16, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Yeoju Korea Rice Toner: My Honest Review and Skincare Results
- November 16, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 30 Pin to USB-C Adapter: Here’s What You Need to Know